My Listings


46 Gnarled Hollow Road
E. Setauket, NY 11733
Total Taxes: $16,033
Status: Sold
MLS#: 3360848
  • , 1 family, Detached
  • Rooms: 10
  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Baths: 2 Full
  • Schools: Three Village
  • Adult Community: N
  • Taxes: $16,033
  • Total Taxes: $16,033
  • Lot Size: 1.07 Acres
  • Lot Sqft: 46609
  • Apx. Year Built: 1750
  • New Construction: N
Allow me to introduce you to 46 Gnarled Hollow Road. This magical and historic circa 1750 gem will take you back to a bygone era. Known as the "Woodhull/Tyler" home, it's countless original features will turn anyone into a history buff. Highlights include 3 wood burning fireplaces, wide plank pine floors, exposed beams, 2 exposed brick chimneys, vintage clawfoot tub, original root cellar, outhouse, and a part original hand-split rail fence. Central air, gas heat (converted 4 years ago,) 200 amp electrical service, new roof, stainless steel kitchen appliances and granite countertops add modern conveniences and upgrades to the picture. A rear studio and separate cottage offer additional space for work/hobbies/gym. Everything on the property is fully CO'd.  Situated on over an acre of serenely private and sprawling landscape, the property is resplendent with places to gather or simply relax and take in the beauty the lush gardens have to offer. Don't miss out on this opportunity!


  • Fireplace: 3


  • Driveway: Pvt
  • Lot Size: 1.07 Acres
  • Lot Sqft: 46609

Room Information

  • Rooms: 10
  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Baths: 2 Full/0 Half
  • # Kitchens: 1


  • Taxes: $16,033
  • Total Taxes: $16,033
  • Bank Owned: N

Other Info

  • Green Features: N

Contact Realtor®

Listing Agent
Lisa F. Hendrickson
(631) 478-1003
Email Me